Summary
- NSC's Q3 revenue fell in the double digit percentage range. Management maintained margins via cost containment efforts.
- Industry rail traffic gained traction in December. Rail traffic should rebound after the economy reopens.
- Chatter suggests an activist investor could show interest in NSC. The stock trades at over 14x EBITDA, but investors should remain disciplined.
- I rate NSC a hold.
- Looking for more investing ideas like this one? Get them exclusively at Shocking The Street. Get started today »
I have been bearish on cyclical names like Norfolk Southern (NSC) for years. The pandemic practically brought business activity to a halt and rail traffic suffered. Pfizer (PFE) has a vaccine that is highly effective at treating COVID-19, which means the economy could reopen early next year. That has brightened the outlook for Norfolk Southern. Combined U.S. rail traffic for the first 49 weeks of 2020 was down 8.1%. However, for the week of December 5th it rose 4.8%, implying business activity was picking up.
In Q3 Norfolk Southern reported revenue of $2.5 billion, down 12% Y/Y. Rail traffic fell 7% Y/Y, while average selling price ("ASP") was off 5%.

Each of the company's key product lines experienced a revenue decline except Automotive, which rose 9%. Coal declined 38%, primarily on a 32% decline in volume. Low natural gas prices and a reduction in global manufacturing due to COVID-19 weighed. COVID-19 hurt demand for Agricultural, which caused the segment to fall in the high-single-digit percentage range. Intermodal revenue fell 1% and will likely track growth in overall rail traffic.
Total rail traffic fell 7%, consistent with the decline in rail traffic for the entire industry.

Each product segment experienced a decline in volume except Automotive and Intermodal. Again, Coal was hard hit by COVID-19 disruptions and competition from natural gas. Agricultural could be a catalyst going forward, given government support to farmers. Intermodal volume benefited from a recovery in supply chain disruptions. It was Norfolk Southern's largest segment at 60% of total rail traffic. The fact that the company's largest segment is showing signs of life bodes well for the future.


