Summary
- Despite having an attractive dividend yield of over 8%, we continue to believe that Altria is an unattractive long-term investment.
- The biggest downside of Altria is that its debt in the last decade has skyrocketed, while its growth stalled and its stock has significantly declined since 2017.
- We believe that it’s not worth purchasing Altria’s stock even at the current levels since its upside is limited.
- Looking for a helping hand in the market? Members of Best Short Ideas get exclusive ideas and guidance to navigate any climate. Get started today »
Despite having an attractive dividend yield of over 8%, we continue to believe that Altria (MO) is an unattractive long-term investment. The biggest downside of Altria is that its debt in the last decade has skyrocketed, while its growth stalled and its stock has significantly declined since 2017. While at this stage Altria generates enough FCF to fund its dividends, the decline in smoking activity will have negative consequences for the company’s financials in the long term. For that reason, we have no position in Altria.
Brace for Challenges Ahead
Altria has been depreciating since the middle of 2017. If you bought its shares at the very top and have not been increasing your position at a lower price as the stock declined, then it’s likely that your total net return is negative even if we include the dividend payments. There’s a possibility that you might recover your losses if the stock starts to significantly recover, but at this stage, we don’t see how the stock will return to its 2017 levels in the foreseeable future. For that reason, holding Altria’s shares solely for the dividend might not be a good long-term strategy, if shares continue to depreciate.

Chart: Google Finance
Altria indeed showed a good performance in Q3, as its revenues increased by 4.8% Y/Y to $5.67 billion, while its non-GAAP EPS of $1.19 was above the consensus by $0.03. For FY20, Altria expects its EPS to be around $4.30 to $4.38 per share.
However, despite such a good performance in times of a pandemic, we believe that Altria’s stock is a value trap. While it has an attractive dividend yield of over 8%, a high payout ratio, and it will be able to generate enough FCF to continue to cover its dividend payments at the current rate, for now, there’s no guarantee that dividend payments will increase in the following years if the business stops performing well. In the last decade, the company’s revenues were relatively flat, while its total debt has skyrocketed from ~$7 billion in 2008 to nearly $30 billion today. Considering this, there’s even a risk that Altria will have no other choice but to cut its dividends if earnings start to deteriorate in the following decade to cover all that debt. For that reason, we believe that the current fair value of Altria is around $30 per share and we have no reason to think that financial and business performance will significantly improve in the foreseeable future.

